Hot Stuff

Weekly Contest: Master Colors
FREE HVC Color Composer
CreativePro.com Podcast
Don't miss it! Updated every Monday.
The Big Picture Magazine - FREE
Real-world solutions to design challenges
Creative Fuel: Believe in Your Unique Value Proposition
Oral history and difficult design clients don't have much in common at first glance. Yet for Molly Joss, these two have paired up as unlikely teachers. The lesson: Don't underestimate your own value.
Written by Molly W. Joss on February 24, 2005
Related Articles
Related Reading
The other day, I was talking to a friend who wants to expand his fledgling freelance writing career. He has a small business creating oral history tapes for families, and he wants to write about the process for a woman's magazine. He'd asked me to critique his article query; that is, the letter he'll send to prospective publishers of his story. During our conversation he told me about the tape he'd made of his grandmother in which she'd mentioned a personal relationship she'd had after her husband died.
As soon as he told me the anecdote, I suggested he change his query. The real story, I said, is your relationship with your grandmother and what made you decide to capture a little of her life on tape. "Any good writer who's done the research could turn out an article on making an oral history tape of a grandparent," I told him. "You're the only person who has shared that experience with your grandmother. You need to have faith that you've got a good story to tell."
That discussion, coupled with a recent decision to fire a client, taught me a valuable lesson these past few weeks. When you run your own company and all you have to sell is you -- whether you're a designer or an artist or a writer -- it's too easy to sell yourself short. You owe it to yourself not to do that.
A Client Not Worth Keeping
I fired the client because I realized finally that the company would never agree to pay me what I'm really worth. It's a non-profit organization with a small budget, so I agreed to an hourly rate that is much lower than my usual fee. Even though the work has grown more complicated over the years, I had never asked for an increase. Needless to say, they'd never offered one, either.
During the several years I worked with this client, I put up with snippy e-mails, demands for re-work, and, generally unacceptable behavior. The more I accommodated, the more the client figured I wasn't going to fight back, and their unprofessional behavior escalated.
I began to change my mind about the client when I started doing similar work for a new client at a much higher hourly rate. This company is happy to pay me the going rate and is happy with the results. Plus, their e-mails and phone calls are professional in wording and manner. The final straw was when I discovered that the problematic client was paying another contractor nearly ten times my hourly rate for comparable work.
I didn't bother raising my rates with the other client. I have learned over the years that clients who pay two contractors vastly different rates for the same kind of work think taking advantage of people is good business. This is not the kind of client you want to keep on the roster.
I'm not a Kenny Rogers fan, but I like his song The Gambler. It contains useful instructions for knowing when the game is finished and it's time to go. Like the song says, "You got to know when to hold 'em, know when to fold 'em, know when to walk away and know when to run..." It was time to fold 'em and walk away from the querulous client.
House Rules
Back to my friend and his article query. He didn't feel that people would want to read about him and his grandmother because he wasn't sure his experiences were more valuable than his information. I'm not sure he believed me when I said his skills can be duplicated but his experiences are what make him irreplaceable.
I can't say that I blame him; on the face of it, there's not much evidence that the world appreciates distinctiveness over information. Maybe what's truly precious is the understanding you gain from your experiences mixed with the skills you derive from knowledge. This is the unique value proposition that all creative professionals have. In other words, nobody can tell your story or do your job the way you do--nobody.
And nobody can take advantage of you without your permission--not for long, that is. It's possible to be caught unaware, and it's kind to give people the benefit of the doubt. Just don't repeat my error. If I had believed in what my work was worth and had been determined that good work is worth good money, I would have fired the client long ago.
Don't let a client bluff you. Believe in yourself and in the unique value of what you do. Then you'll be holding a winning hand.
Read more by Molly Joss.
Login
Login to post a comment. Not a member? Sign up here
Forgot your password?











Great topic and article
Thank you for writing on such a valuable topic - our value. It's so easy to undervalue/seek approval, and so hard to see my worth. I do once I realize that I really undercharged. :) Well written.
Really great article!
Really great article!
Firing Clients
Well said. Especially the part about being caught unawares - that happened to me a lot in the early part of my career, mainly because I assumed that people I considered friends wouldn't try to cheat me.
Live and learn, I guess.
Bret Taylor
howyadoin graphics
Wow! Best use of Kenny Rogers lyrics...
Best use of not only Kenny Rogers' lyrics, but advice I can take to heart on two fronts: knowing when I'm being taken advantage of by a client and doing something about it for starters, and furthermore, thinking about the value of my experiences NOT JUST my skills.
Judging the value of our work
This article resonated very strongly with me, albeit in a different manner than with most of those who have responded so far. Although I truly understand the dilemma of dealing with clients that undervalue my value to them (or even the value of good design work no matter who does it for them) I was engaged and drawn in by the information in the article that spoke of the client who thought writing about the process of documenting his grandmother's story was more important than telling the story itself (and also the story of the relationship between he and his grandmother).
My connection to the article and to the client mentioned is that I write creative non-fiction and personal story as part of my art (I also do fiber arts, sculpture, graphic design, digital art and photography). Of all the art that I do, I find story the hardest to value. However, I think that it has the potential for containing the most Worth...
As a MFA candidate studying for a degree in Interdisciplinary Art I began with (and occasionally return to) this very essential struggle – judging the value of my work. The notion that the work I did had value was difficult for me. Like the client with the grandmother stories, I had no concept of the worth of what I created (or could create). Even though I knew my art had monetary value (each piece sold for hundreds – or even thousands – of dollars), I was unsure that it had any value other than that of a decoration in the homes of the affluent. I was unsure it had any true Worth. It became imminently clear to me as I wrestled with this concept that I had to decide if I wanted my artwork to have a social value also – a worth beyond being a beautiful "thing."
Was I being the change I wanted to see in the world?
In the growth that naturally occurs in any honest course of study (be it formal education or rigorous self examination) I have come to see that my work must have some sort of value (other than sales value) for me to be content with it, and as a result, the work I do has changed. It no longer is quite as marketable as it once was. That's okay – I have a day job – and I'd rather make art that satisfies me and conveys the meaning I want it to express rather than make lots of money selling my art... I have become willing to risk telling the story itself rather than talking about how to make the story.
WOW design with common sense: GREAT
Last month I provided help to three designers (new graduates entering the job market) who had not been paid for design work. They were going to simply advertise the "bad client" via magazine article (because that Bad Client was running a new advertisement for Entry Level Design Position) and non-payment issue was pending after months of unanswered inquiries.
My advise was the same as Molly so beautifully put it: Move on, and drop the client; with added suggestion, to communicate with all clients up front; let them know you expect them to reward your effort with a fair price (call the Better Business Bureau and file a claim in small claims court for any dead beats).
My suggestion:
Stop talking price and begin offering value by interviewing each client (to know their needs) and make sure they can and will pay for your expertise. We put too much attention on price and not enough energy into the client/designer relationship. Look for a good relationship and everyone wins.
Terrific article, suggest more of same in future.
Created unique we each have value
Thanks for the refreshing article. Taking a leap of faith and sharing who you are not what you are is always a challenge. Thanks for encourageing your friend to walk the road less travelled and share his grandma's life lessons. Good on you for not submitting to fear of "loosing a client" and knowing your worth. I too, and I'm sure every one of us struggles with our marketable value but we must not sell ourselves short as we are uniquely gifted for a purpose. Pride is not the answer but rolling over and taking a beating won't do either. Shine for who we are and create from your heart and being! Good job.
How timely!
I was originally Googling to find a definition for unique value proposal and I found more than I expected in the article. It gave me additional insight into the value I bring to the table when promoting my skill-set. Thanks!
Helpful topic well told
Want to tell Molly Joss directly, THANK YOU. Very important point, well told. Going through that very experience myself right now.
Recently I had to fire a client
The article is right-on! I had to fire a client because after they assigned the jobs they never provided the needed content for the jobs. They would then call me very angry why the job was not progressing. I just told them that I can't make-up your content or read your companies mind on your content, you need to provide that at the very least. Then I fired them on the next phone call they made about the works progress. Best move I ever made.